Too Faced 3-pack Killer Liner Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

No way to sharpen so the liner you see on the pencil is what you get.

Complete waste of money. There is no way to get more product out of the plastic non-sharpable "pencil". There is only enough product to last a few applications, then the plastic "pencil" is trash. Deceiving to the consumer and environmentally irresponsible. Disappointed in both, Too Faced and HSN. Your customers are intelligent people who understand quality. It's hard to take you seriously after this, HSN and Too Faced. Should have read the other reviews before ordering; too late to return.

I tried it on with cream eye shadow and powder eye shadow. Either way the eyeliner color would stick to the top of my eyelids. During the day it would smudged. I had to return it :/.

too faced 3 pack liner is a waste of money, the pencils do not sharpen or raise from the tube. When they arrived the tips were very soft and they break. I only got a few uses out of each pencil.

Does not sharpen well at all. Very choppy and worse than pencil shavings when sharpened. I would not recommend. It is nice until you have to sharpen it....

I liked the color and the smooth application. It only sharpens best with electric sharpener. The casing is plastic, so small sharp pieces stick out. Very painful. Could do damage to your eye.

I bought this on clearance, in fact, I thought it was such a good deal I bought 2 sets! Its awful!!! Doesnt stay on, can barely sharpen! I find it hard to believe that they and HSN would actually put such an inferior product out.

Too smudgy. Too late to return and I wish I didn't have 3 of them. I am throwing one out and giving the others away.

Ordered and shipped but,never received

These pencils are useless. I have used four different sharpeners and the tip breaks off. The outside of the pencil is to hard and cannot be sharpened. I would send back but would cost too much to mess with. Dont purchase or you will be disappointed.

Im glad I bought these when they were 3 for $17 I have used two and when you get to where the wording starts they are empty after that so youre paying for only half a pencil they do stay on well but I wouldnt buy them again because of the amount of empty pencil its a rip off

The liner is very nice, but impossible to sharpen. It liner continually broke when a happened with a normal eye liner sharpener. Had to pitch each one after four uses.

I was so excited to get these but dont waste your Money they arent very good .

These eyeliners seem waterproof but smudges if use on the waterline. Very difficult to sharpen because the produce is soft. Save Your money and invest in a thin liner

The liner is great, stayed on like it says, but, they are not self sharpening..so,kind of a waste, now I have buy a sharpener, and they just don't work..so I won't buy again